Which Is Better A Shingle Or Metal Roof?

A shingle or metal roof refers to the material used for roofing construction. Asphalt shingle roofs are composed of shingles made from fiberglass mats coated with asphalt. Metal roofs are made from steel, aluminum, copper or other alloy panels.

Debating your roofing options and wondering Which Is Better A Shingle Or Metal Roof? This guide will help you decide! Compare the pros and cons of asphalt shingles versus metal panels based on cost, longevity, weather resistance, maintenance needs, aesthetics, and environmental impact.

Choosing asphalt shingles or metal panels requires comparing key factors from cost to sustainability. Keep reading to learn the pros and cons of each durable roofing based on weather resistance, longevity, maintenance, aesthetics and your budget. Get the facts to determine the best material for your home.

Key Takeaways

  • Metal for durability, shingles for affordability and variety.
  • Metal’s resilience vs. shingle’s budget-friendly option.
  • Tailor decision to personal preferences and budget constraints.

How Do Metal & Shingle Roof Materials Compare?

AspectMetal RoofShingle Roof
DurabilityHighly durableLess durable
CostHigher initial costLower initial cost
LongevityLonger lifespanShorter lifespan
MaintenanceLow maintenanceRegular maintenance
InstallationComplex installationSimple installation

Metal roofs are durable; they last longer than shingles. Metal resists weathering, preventing leaks common in shingle roofs. With metal, worry less about repairs.

Shingle roofs offer affordability, good for tight budgets. Easy to install, they suit various architectural styles. Shingles come in diverse colors, enhancing curb appeal.

Metal roofs are energy-efficient, reflecting sunlight to reduce cooling costs. Shingles, on the other hand, absorb heat, making interiors warmer. When choosing between metal’s coolness and shingle’s warmth, consider climate. Install vents on a metal roof to optimize ventilation and enhance energy efficiency further.


Metal roofs outlast shingles, boasting a longer lifespan. Shingles, though more affordable, may require replacement sooner. Opt for metal if longevity is a priority, ensuring enduring protection for your home.

Energy Efficiency

When comparing metal and shingle roofs, energy efficiency tips towards metal. Metal reflects sunlight, lowering cooling costs. In contrast, shingles absorb heat, potentially raising interior temperatures. Consider your climate and energy bills when choosing between the two materials.


Metal roofs are lightweight, reducing stress on the structure. This makes them ideal for various architectural designs. Shingle roofs, though heavier, still offer versatility in installation. Consider the weight impact on your building when choosing between the two materials.


Metal roofs are quieter during rain; raindrops make a softer sound. Shingle roofs, however, can amplify the noise of rainfall. When considering peace and quiet, metal may be the better choice for a tranquil home environment.

Weather Resistance (Snow, Hail, High Winds)

In harsh weather, metal excels. It withstands heavy snow, preventing buildup. Metal’s durability shines against hail, avoiding damage common with shingles. When winds roar, metal stays put, offering reliable protection compared to shingles.

So, Which Roof Do We Think Has the Best Material?

In weighing metal against shingle roofing, the choice boils down to priorities. If longevity and durability top the list, metal shines with its resilience. Yet, for those on a budget, shingles provide an economical alternative. The decision hinges on factors like climate, budget, and desired aesthetics, making each roofing material a contender based on individual needs.

Benefits of Metal Roofing Over Shingle Roofing

Benefits of Metal Roofing Over Shingle Roofing

Metal roofing outshines shingles in durability, lasting decades without deterioration. It reflects sunlight, cutting energy costs, and requires minimal maintenance.

Longevity: Metal roofs have a longer lifespan compared to shingles.

Durability: They resist weathering, preventing leaks common in shingle roofs.

Energy Efficiency: Reflecting sunlight, metal reduces cooling costs.

Low Maintenance: Metal roofs require minimal upkeep over the years.

Environmentally Friendly: Many metal roofs are recyclable, reducing environmental impact.

Aesthetic Variety: Metal comes in various styles and colors, enhancing curb appeal.

Weather Resistance: With superior weather resistance, metal is a reliable choice.

Choose metal for a resilient, eco-friendly, and cost-effective roofing solution.

Metal Roofing More Durable Than Shingle Roofing

When it comes to durability, metal roofing takes the lead. It withstands harsh weather conditions, from heavy snow to scorching sun, without deteriorating. With a longer lifespan than shingles, metal proves a robust choice for those seeking a resilient roofing solution.

Metal’s durability also extends to resisting rust and corrosion, common issues with other materials. Its sturdy nature means fewer repairs and replacements over the years. Opting for metal roofing translates to a reliable, long-lasting investment that stands up to the elements, ensuring a durable shelter for years to come.

There Different Types of Metal Roofing Materials

There Different Types of Metal Roofing Materials

Metal roofing offers diverse options, each with distinct benefits. Corrugated metal, known for its strength, suits various climates. Standing seam metal, with its sleek appearance, excels in shedding water, preventing leaks.

Another popular choice is metal shingles, combining durability with a classic look. They imitate traditional materials but outlast them. With metal roofing, variety meets durability, letting homeowners tailor their choice to both style and practicality.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is more expensive metal or shingles?

Metal roofing tends to be more expensive than shingles due to its durability and longevity, offering a longer-term investment in comparison to the affordability of shingle roofs.

Which roof type is best?

The best roof type depends on individual priorities and needs, with factors like budget, climate, and aesthetic preferences playing crucial roles in the decision-making process.

What are the disadvantages of a shingle roof?

Shingle roofs may require more frequent replacement due to wear and tear. Additionally, they can be prone to wind damage in severe weather conditions.


In the end, the choice between a shingle or metal roof boils down to priorities. For those valuing affordability and diverse aesthetic options, shingle roofs prove a worthy contender. However, if durability, longevity, and energy efficiency are paramount, metal roofs shine as the superior choice.

Considering the weather resistance, cost-effectiveness, and curb appeal, homeowners must weigh the pros and cons. While shingle roofs offer a budget-friendly solution with a range of styles, metal roofs present a robust, long-term investment. In the debate of which is better, it ultimately depends on individual needs and preferences, aligning the practicalities of metal with the versatility of shingles.

Leave a Comment